
From Marc Berman at the Programming Insider:
America’s Next Top Model - 3.98 million
Smallville - 3.96 million
Supernatural - 2.55 million
Reaper - 2.47 million
One Tree Hill - 2.28 million
Gossip Girl - 2.12 million
Farmer Wants a Wife - 2.11 million
Beauty and the Geek - 1.63 million
The Game - 1.44 million
Everybody Hates Chris - 1.24 million
Aliens in America - 1.04 million
Feel free to repost this information, but if you do, please credit me, as it takes me awhile each week to compile all of this. Thank you!
For easy reference/comparison, ranked from highest to lowest:
Bedtime Stories - 3.24 million
Jus in Bello - 3.23 million
Sin City - 3.18 million
The Kids are All Right - 3.16 million
Bad Day at Black Rock - 3.03 million
A Very Supernatural Christmas - 3.02 million (pre-empted in Denver)
Red Sky at Morning - 3.01 million
Mystery Spot - 2.97 million (delayed in North Carolina)
The Magnificent Seven - 2.97 million
Malleus Maleficarum - 2.95 million
Fresh Blood - 2.88 million
Dream a Little Dream of Me - 2.67 million
Long Distance Call - 2.63 million
Time is On My Side - 2.55 million
Ghostfacers - 2.22 million (pre-empted in Chicago)