![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
agt_spookyOk, here we go - Tina Charles has put up her review of What Is and What Should Never Be from tvguide.com
Supernatural
by Bettina Charles
May 3, 2007: What Is And What Should Never Be
Sorry that this is so late guys! Work sucks. 'Nuff said. (Now get ready for a long, long post)
Anyway, that was as good as I had hoped. And consider me as big a wuss as Sammy was in the alternate reality of Dean's because that just shattered my heart into so many pieces. You know how Jared's best episode was BUABS? Well, let me just say right now: this was Jensen's best episode — not only of the season but the series. Thanks to superior writing by Raelle Tucker, Jensen had me laughing, tearing up, kept me on an emotional rollercoaster the entire hour. I'm not exaggerating here. He. Was. Awesome.
There's so much to talk about I don't even think I'll be able to sound coherent. Gotta say that Dean was kind of stupid for not listening to Sammy and going into that abandoned building alone. That djinn got the drop on him pretty quickly and sent Dean into an alternate reality where Mom is alive; Dad is dead (via stroke, not a deal with the Demon); Dean and Sammy don't get along; Jess is alive and Dean's got a girlfriend. This is as normal as normal can get. It was simply crushing when Dean sees his mom for the first time. Before he can let himself believe it's really his mom, he asks her what she used to tell him when she used to put him to bed as a kid. Like we learned in "Houses of the Holy", she told him that angels were watching over him. Hearing her reply enabled him to give in to the reality that was before him.
It's sad that just because you get your wish doesn't mean you're happy. In this other world, Dean's not such a great person. Mom and Sam automatically think that Dean's been drinking. He doesn't seem like he was someone that helped around the house; he hooked up with Sam's prom date on the night of Sam's prom; he snaked Sam's ATM card and bailed on his graduation. And when Dean comes up with that owing a bookie story, Sam totally believes that's logical. So, to see Dean being all earnest and big brotherly and have everybody question his motives, that's sad. Dean got his wish that his mother was alive but in a world where she exists, he and Sam aren't tight. They barely speak other than on holidays and mom's birthday. Some other moments that just broke my heart:
—Mom comforting Dean, kissing him on the forehead and wondering if he was really all right. Telling him she loves him.
—When Dean saw Jess for the first time — the way he hugged her as if he knew her more than the one time he met her. He was just so happy that Sam could have Jess back.
—Giving into the whole girlfriend thing — he realized that Carmen knew him so well. It was nice to see him have a significant other, especially one that seemed to be so strongly on his side.
—Yes, even Dean eating a sandwich was heartbreaking, because his mom made it for him. It's something that hasn't happened for him in over 20 years, if ever.
—To have Sam and Dean sitting down at an actual family dinner was something I've been waiting for since the show started. Dean just taking it in, getting enjoyment out of seeing his family together = heartbreaking moment.
—Seeing all these ghostly figures and hanging bodies appear to Dean and then having him realize little by little that something's up big time. Then realizing that everyone he, his dad and Sam saved in their world, died in this alternate reality. There's no way he was going to be able to stay knowing that.
—When alternate-reality Sam tells Dean that they just don't have anything in common. So sad.
—Dean wanting to make everything up to everyone. And knowing that it's not going to happen because none of it's real.
—Dean's tearful monologuing at BDW's grave. Crushing.
—The last ditch effort to get Dean to choose the new reality and let his body die was too painful for words. You know for a little bit he wanted to do it. Just like he wanted to take that deal to get his dad back. But he's noble and he knew that he couldn't do it.
—Dean stabbing himself.
—Dean opening up to Sam about how much this job has cost them.
How great was Dean mowing the lawn? Even wanting to mow the lawn? Again, he seemed to just want to do all these normal things. During Season 1, I would have said it was impossible that Dean would think any of these thoughts (other than wanting his mom alive); during Season 2, the writers and Eric Kripke did a really great job with planting the seeds of doubt where Dean and hunting are concerned. We've heard more than once that he was thinking maybe it was time for them to take a break, that maybe he and Sam could step back from playing the heroes for a while. Maybe take off for Amsterdam, even. But, even though his wanting normal isn't a surprise, the whole wanting to mow the lawn was just funny and it all seemed right. And, the actual mowing, complete with the rockin' version of "What a Wonderful World," was hilarious. But did you check the neighbor guy? Even he seemed dubious at Dean being all friendly and waving at him. Oh, alternate-reality Dean.
Even though this wasn't Sam's POV or anything, it was really nice to see Sam with Jessica. At the end of last year, I got the chance to interview Adrianne Palicki (who plays Jessica) and I asked her if she'd ever consider going back to Supernatural if they asked and she said yes. So it was great to see her, especially since we hadn't seen her since she was an apparition on the side of the road in "Bloody Mary." Here's to hoping Friday Night Lights gets renewed for a second season (not sure if it has been or not). He was such a wuss on that hunt. Although I guess he's allowed too — it was his first hunt.
This whole alternate journey of Dean's: Aside from, confirming that Sam and Dean's path is to help people, save them from the things that go bump in the night, it was all about brotherhood. Would Dean be willing to live in a reality where he and Sam just didn't get along? Would he have been able to fix things? Who knows. What we all do know is that Dean and Sam are meant to be tight, they are meant to be fighting demons and spirits and saving people's lives. This episode touched on the heart of Supernatural: brotherly love, sense of duty, saving the lives of people who don't know what's truly out there. So yes, this episode was heartbreaking, but it was a little uplifting as well. As you can tell, I just adored "What Is and What Should Never Be."
Other thoughts:
—I thought the glamour shot of Carmen that was in the apartment she shared with Dean was kinda weird. Good to know it was actually the same shot as some beer ad that Dean had seen in a magazine.
—Loved how awkward Dean was when he first "met" Carmen. That kiss was appropriately unsexy.
—The pictures that they photo-shopped together using Jensen and Jared's pictures from when they were young were so great to see, weren't they?
—Did BDW's tombstone say: John B. Winchester? What's the B for?
—It was weird to see the Impala with different license plates.
—They sort of recreated that scene from the pilot where Dean breaks into Sam's place. That was cool.
—I sort of wish we got to see Sam looking for Dean in the present, but that would have been jarring.
—I've been waiting for Mary to return and she finally did. Although the character looked tired, she didn't look like she had aged all that much from when Dean as 4.
—I wish we could have seen more of Jess.
—Love Sam being so sure of what he and Dean need to be doing. Remember last year, he was full of doubt. Now, he's strong, he's confident and he knows what needs to be done. It's so great to see.
—I was so anticipating this episode, I re-watched the pilot.
—I'm so glad that Dean opened up to Sammy about his experience. I wasn't sure if he was going to.
—Everybody and everything seems to get how much pain Dean's in and has experienced.
—This reminded me of the Buffy episode called "Normal Again." Loved WIAWSNB just as much as I loved that sixth-season episode. (Maybe even a little more)
—I'm glad Dean got to kill the djinn and he got to save the girl's life. Loved Sam's look as Dean told the girl he had her.
Favorite Lines:
—"I'm just happy to see you, that's all. You're beautiful!"
—"You kidding? I love your lectures. You make learning fun."
—"Son?" "Hmm..." "You been drinking?" "Everybody keeps asking me that. But, uh, no"
—"Who'd have thought, baby? We're civilians."
—"How did I end up with such a cool chick?" "You've just got low standards."
—"I'm dating a nurse. That is so respectable."
—"Why do I have to be some kind of hero?"
—"Dean, what the hell are you doing here?" "I was looking for a beer."
—"I can't believe we're even related." "Sam, I'm sorry. I'm sorry that we don't get along."
—"Tell mom I love her."
—"Bitch." "What are you calling me a bitch for?" "You're supposed to say jerk." "What?" "Never mind."
—"You're having a psychotic breakdown." "I wish."
—"No, I'm pretty sure. Like, 90 percent sure."
—"You're not real. None of it is." "It doesn't matter. It's still better than anything you had."
—"Why is it our job to save everyone? Haven't we done enough? I'm begging you, give me the knife."
—"I'm sorry."
—"Auntie Em, there's no place like home."
—"I thought I lost you for a second." "You almost did."
—"You were such a wussy."
—"I'm glad you dug yourself out, Dean."
—"It's worth it."
~~~~
Word, Tina. Just...word. Your review rocks. And I'm still broken.
Supernatural
by Bettina Charles
May 3, 2007: What Is And What Should Never Be
Sorry that this is so late guys! Work sucks. 'Nuff said. (Now get ready for a long, long post)
Anyway, that was as good as I had hoped. And consider me as big a wuss as Sammy was in the alternate reality of Dean's because that just shattered my heart into so many pieces. You know how Jared's best episode was BUABS? Well, let me just say right now: this was Jensen's best episode — not only of the season but the series. Thanks to superior writing by Raelle Tucker, Jensen had me laughing, tearing up, kept me on an emotional rollercoaster the entire hour. I'm not exaggerating here. He. Was. Awesome.
There's so much to talk about I don't even think I'll be able to sound coherent. Gotta say that Dean was kind of stupid for not listening to Sammy and going into that abandoned building alone. That djinn got the drop on him pretty quickly and sent Dean into an alternate reality where Mom is alive; Dad is dead (via stroke, not a deal with the Demon); Dean and Sammy don't get along; Jess is alive and Dean's got a girlfriend. This is as normal as normal can get. It was simply crushing when Dean sees his mom for the first time. Before he can let himself believe it's really his mom, he asks her what she used to tell him when she used to put him to bed as a kid. Like we learned in "Houses of the Holy", she told him that angels were watching over him. Hearing her reply enabled him to give in to the reality that was before him.
It's sad that just because you get your wish doesn't mean you're happy. In this other world, Dean's not such a great person. Mom and Sam automatically think that Dean's been drinking. He doesn't seem like he was someone that helped around the house; he hooked up with Sam's prom date on the night of Sam's prom; he snaked Sam's ATM card and bailed on his graduation. And when Dean comes up with that owing a bookie story, Sam totally believes that's logical. So, to see Dean being all earnest and big brotherly and have everybody question his motives, that's sad. Dean got his wish that his mother was alive but in a world where she exists, he and Sam aren't tight. They barely speak other than on holidays and mom's birthday. Some other moments that just broke my heart:
—Mom comforting Dean, kissing him on the forehead and wondering if he was really all right. Telling him she loves him.
—When Dean saw Jess for the first time — the way he hugged her as if he knew her more than the one time he met her. He was just so happy that Sam could have Jess back.
—Giving into the whole girlfriend thing — he realized that Carmen knew him so well. It was nice to see him have a significant other, especially one that seemed to be so strongly on his side.
—Yes, even Dean eating a sandwich was heartbreaking, because his mom made it for him. It's something that hasn't happened for him in over 20 years, if ever.
—To have Sam and Dean sitting down at an actual family dinner was something I've been waiting for since the show started. Dean just taking it in, getting enjoyment out of seeing his family together = heartbreaking moment.
—Seeing all these ghostly figures and hanging bodies appear to Dean and then having him realize little by little that something's up big time. Then realizing that everyone he, his dad and Sam saved in their world, died in this alternate reality. There's no way he was going to be able to stay knowing that.
—When alternate-reality Sam tells Dean that they just don't have anything in common. So sad.
—Dean wanting to make everything up to everyone. And knowing that it's not going to happen because none of it's real.
—Dean's tearful monologuing at BDW's grave. Crushing.
—The last ditch effort to get Dean to choose the new reality and let his body die was too painful for words. You know for a little bit he wanted to do it. Just like he wanted to take that deal to get his dad back. But he's noble and he knew that he couldn't do it.
—Dean stabbing himself.
—Dean opening up to Sam about how much this job has cost them.
How great was Dean mowing the lawn? Even wanting to mow the lawn? Again, he seemed to just want to do all these normal things. During Season 1, I would have said it was impossible that Dean would think any of these thoughts (other than wanting his mom alive); during Season 2, the writers and Eric Kripke did a really great job with planting the seeds of doubt where Dean and hunting are concerned. We've heard more than once that he was thinking maybe it was time for them to take a break, that maybe he and Sam could step back from playing the heroes for a while. Maybe take off for Amsterdam, even. But, even though his wanting normal isn't a surprise, the whole wanting to mow the lawn was just funny and it all seemed right. And, the actual mowing, complete with the rockin' version of "What a Wonderful World," was hilarious. But did you check the neighbor guy? Even he seemed dubious at Dean being all friendly and waving at him. Oh, alternate-reality Dean.
Even though this wasn't Sam's POV or anything, it was really nice to see Sam with Jessica. At the end of last year, I got the chance to interview Adrianne Palicki (who plays Jessica) and I asked her if she'd ever consider going back to Supernatural if they asked and she said yes. So it was great to see her, especially since we hadn't seen her since she was an apparition on the side of the road in "Bloody Mary." Here's to hoping Friday Night Lights gets renewed for a second season (not sure if it has been or not). He was such a wuss on that hunt. Although I guess he's allowed too — it was his first hunt.
This whole alternate journey of Dean's: Aside from, confirming that Sam and Dean's path is to help people, save them from the things that go bump in the night, it was all about brotherhood. Would Dean be willing to live in a reality where he and Sam just didn't get along? Would he have been able to fix things? Who knows. What we all do know is that Dean and Sam are meant to be tight, they are meant to be fighting demons and spirits and saving people's lives. This episode touched on the heart of Supernatural: brotherly love, sense of duty, saving the lives of people who don't know what's truly out there. So yes, this episode was heartbreaking, but it was a little uplifting as well. As you can tell, I just adored "What Is and What Should Never Be."
Other thoughts:
—I thought the glamour shot of Carmen that was in the apartment she shared with Dean was kinda weird. Good to know it was actually the same shot as some beer ad that Dean had seen in a magazine.
—Loved how awkward Dean was when he first "met" Carmen. That kiss was appropriately unsexy.
—The pictures that they photo-shopped together using Jensen and Jared's pictures from when they were young were so great to see, weren't they?
—Did BDW's tombstone say: John B. Winchester? What's the B for?
—It was weird to see the Impala with different license plates.
—They sort of recreated that scene from the pilot where Dean breaks into Sam's place. That was cool.
—I sort of wish we got to see Sam looking for Dean in the present, but that would have been jarring.
—I've been waiting for Mary to return and she finally did. Although the character looked tired, she didn't look like she had aged all that much from when Dean as 4.
—I wish we could have seen more of Jess.
—Love Sam being so sure of what he and Dean need to be doing. Remember last year, he was full of doubt. Now, he's strong, he's confident and he knows what needs to be done. It's so great to see.
—I was so anticipating this episode, I re-watched the pilot.
—I'm so glad that Dean opened up to Sammy about his experience. I wasn't sure if he was going to.
—Everybody and everything seems to get how much pain Dean's in and has experienced.
—This reminded me of the Buffy episode called "Normal Again." Loved WIAWSNB just as much as I loved that sixth-season episode. (Maybe even a little more)
—I'm glad Dean got to kill the djinn and he got to save the girl's life. Loved Sam's look as Dean told the girl he had her.
Favorite Lines:
—"I'm just happy to see you, that's all. You're beautiful!"
—"You kidding? I love your lectures. You make learning fun."
—"Son?" "Hmm..." "You been drinking?" "Everybody keeps asking me that. But, uh, no"
—"Who'd have thought, baby? We're civilians."
—"How did I end up with such a cool chick?" "You've just got low standards."
—"I'm dating a nurse. That is so respectable."
—"Why do I have to be some kind of hero?"
—"Dean, what the hell are you doing here?" "I was looking for a beer."
—"I can't believe we're even related." "Sam, I'm sorry. I'm sorry that we don't get along."
—"Tell mom I love her."
—"Bitch." "What are you calling me a bitch for?" "You're supposed to say jerk." "What?" "Never mind."
—"You're having a psychotic breakdown." "I wish."
—"No, I'm pretty sure. Like, 90 percent sure."
—"You're not real. None of it is." "It doesn't matter. It's still better than anything you had."
—"Why is it our job to save everyone? Haven't we done enough? I'm begging you, give me the knife."
—"I'm sorry."
—"Auntie Em, there's no place like home."
—"I thought I lost you for a second." "You almost did."
—"You were such a wussy."
—"I'm glad you dug yourself out, Dean."
—"It's worth it."
~~~~
Word, Tina. Just...word. Your review rocks. And I'm still broken.
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
(no subject)
Date: 2007-05-04 05:08 pm (UTC)About what Tina said about season 1 dean not wanting this - I did remember his line in BUGS that if he had to live in a normal neighborhood he'd shoot himself - you liar, Dean!
Also, I'm pretty sure from the pics the set visitors took of the gravestone that it's John E. Winchester.
I also liked the part in the beginning (I know it was a Director's Cut) where Sam is worried about the police car. Good continuity from FPB.
Dean SO wants Mommy to caress his face. Awwww.
And I know that JDM couldn't fit filming into his schedule, but in Supernatural-verse, it's kinda interesting to think that Dean couldn't even imagine John without hunting.
I know Dean's never said anything about this, but they should have had a dog!
Was that a porn mag in the Imapala's trunk? *LOL*
(no subject)
Date: 2007-05-04 06:50 pm (UTC)As usual, I think Tina really hit it on the head. This episode was just heartbreaking, as I expected it to be. It's so awful that without hunting, Sam and Dean don't have anything in common, but it makes sense, in a way. They're so different from each other that if they had had a normal life, staying in one place and going to school, that they would have ended up with their own totally different groups of friends and wouldn't have needed to become so close.
"Bitch." "What are you calling me a bitch for?" "You're supposed to say jerk." "What?" "Never mind."
Ahh, that part killed me (well...along with the rest of the episode...)! It was completely brilliant, though; it was such a simple thing to add in but was really poignant, I thought. It's one of those little things that people who are close to each other have, and even it doesn't exist in that reality. *tear*
"What Is/Never Be"
Date: 2007-05-05 02:46 am (UTC)Back to the ep. Loved seeing Dean waking up next to another hot babe(yeah, yeah)who he doesn't know very well(triple yeah)...and then Raelle reunites Dean with Mary. Migod, that part just gets to me. Dean interrogates his mother as tough, badass Dean, but when she gives the right answer he just crumbles. He glows. He's radiant with joy, being able to talk with and touch Mary again, and to see all those new family pictures(I'm still sorry that JDM wasn't in the ep, but his presence was definitely there). The lawnmowing scene and his squeezing Jess were hilarious. He's just so damn happy living a normal life with the weight of hunting off his shoulders that you want it to be real for him.
Sam asks Dean at the end why wasn't it a perfect life, why were he and Dean estranged? Dunno. Maybe because so many tales about wishes granted usually don't end happily. Maybe because Dean went off alone after arguing with Sam. Maybe because there had to be some karmic price to be paid to spare Mary and give Sam Jess.(It was clever to replay part of the pilot, even right down to Jess shifting in bed, tho Sam shows off a deliciously bigger bicep than he had in Season 1!)
The climax, where Dean is tempted to take the Djinn's offer, was just heartbreaking. Jensen was superb, turning his face into Mary's palm even tho he knows now that his 'second chance' was a lie. He is torn in two, and I think he believed he could heal the split between him and Sam. That is Dean's biggest strength and his worst weakness, so stubbornly, absolutely believing that he can, with time and hard work, fix anything, from the Impala to Sam. Wow. If "Born/Sign" was Jared's time to shine, this was definitely Jensen's night.
Bring on the season (SEASON, Kripke, SEASON)finale!!
(no subject)
Date: 2007-05-07 02:23 pm (UTC)LOL! Totally! You're busted, Dean!
Also, I'm pretty sure from the pics the set visitors took of the gravestone that it's John E. Winchester.
Yeah, I agree that it was an E on the tombstone. Hmm...wonder what it stands for?
I also liked the part in the beginning (I know it was a Director's Cut) where Sam is worried about the police car. Good continuity from FPB.
For the most part, SPN has the most consistant continuity of any show I've watched. And I loved that the were in Joliet, IL - only about 25 minutes away from where I live!
Dean SO wants Mommy to caress his face. Awwww.
Oh god, the way he leaned into her touch - broke my heart.
And I know that JDM couldn't fit filming into his schedule, but in Supernatural-verse, it's kinda interesting to think that Dean couldn't even imagine John without hunting.
Yeah, he was so stunned with the softball picture and that John died of a stroke. But happy that his dad didn't die because he sacrificed himself for Dean.
Was that a porn mag in the Imapala's trunk? *LOL*
Actually, it looked like Maxim - the magazine that Sandy did that photo spread in!
(no subject)
Date: 2007-05-07 02:33 pm (UTC)That's my problem, too! I usually have a lot to say about each episode, but I just couldn't string more than a few words together this time. I had to let Tina do the talking for me this time. :-)
As usual, I think Tina really hit it on the head.
I love her reviews. She's such the fangirl and it's rare that I disagree with her.
Sam and Dean don't have anything in common, but it makes sense, in a way. They're so different from each other
That's very, very true. Sam would've gone off to school just like we were shown and without being in the same state, I could easily see them growing apart. So sad! That's the part that really broke me - the closeness they had was just gone.
It's one of those little things that people who are close to each other have, and even it doesn't exist in that reality. *tear*
At first I laughed at that exchange, then it hit me that it was actually quite sad, that they didn't even have that simple thing anymore. [sniff]
Even through all the sadness, this episode is a winner in my book.
Re: "What Is/Never Be"
Date: 2007-05-07 02:53 pm (UTC)Yeah, I mean how many times has something like this been done? But never have I been so affected by an episode like that. Between Raelle writing it and Eric directing it - a winning combination for sure.
Jensen acted with force and pain and passion(and I SO envy you ladies who are gonna get a taste of that in person!).
Jensen was freaking amazing in this episode. BUABS was Jared's moment to shine and WIAWSNB was Jensen's turn. Damn, both of these boys are fantastic actors.
Remember how in "Salvation" John said, 'I want you (Sam) to go to school, I want Dean to have a home. I want Mary alive'? I guess you really should be careful what you wish for...
Yes! Again with the continuity!
Dean interrogates his mother as tough, badass Dean
As I would expect him to, since he was so disbelieving as to what was going on.
but when she gives the right answer he just crumbles. He glows. He's radiant with joy, being able to talk with and touch Mary again
You should've seen me, yelling out the answer right before Mary did. :-) And Dean, like you said, it's like he sags with relief, that yes, Mary really is in front of him.
and to see all those new family pictures(I'm still sorry that JDM wasn't in the ep, but his presence was definitely there)
All of those pictures were fantastic! A great way to show snippets of their lives and to bring JDM into the show.
The lawnmowing scene and his squeezing Jess were hilarious. He's just so damn happy living a normal life with the weight of hunting off his shoulders that you want it to be real for him.
I think I hurt something laughing at that and the sandwich eating. :-) Nice to see a couple of light moments in an otherwise heartwrenching episode.
It was clever to replay part of the pilot, even right down to Jess shifting in bed, tho Sam shows off a deliciously bigger bicep than he had in Season 1!)
Oh, that was freaking brilliant! Kudos to Raelle for writing it that way.
He is torn in two, and I think he believed he could heal the split between him and Sam. That is Dean's biggest strength and his worst weakness
Wow, yeah, you really hit the nail on the head. He's so heartbroken that he and Sam are miles apart and he's determined to fix that, no matter what.
Bring on the season (SEASON, Kripke, SEASON)finale!!
That's right! SEASON finale! :-)