I hated Tall Tales with a passion. It actually made me detest Dean as a character.
So my choice came down to Hell House and Hollywood Babylon.
I adored PA!Dean and loved all the meta. I'm big into shows that self reference as that's a big payoff for me being a regular viewer. Sadly Sam was a pale shadow of himself in HB, totally understandable imo, but it left a Sam sized hole in the episode.
In HH, towelclad!Sam made me all squishy and happy, despite me being a Dean!girl. Plus the story seemed to hang together better and fit in the arc of the season comfortably despite being completely different in tone.
no subject
So my choice came down to Hell House and Hollywood Babylon.
I adored PA!Dean and loved all the meta. I'm big into shows that self reference as that's a big payoff for me being a regular viewer. Sadly Sam was a pale shadow of himself in HB, totally understandable imo, but it left a Sam sized hole in the episode.
In HH, towelclad!Sam made me all squishy and happy, despite me being a Dean!girl. Plus the story seemed to hang together better and fit in the arc of the season comfortably despite being completely different in tone.
Thus I voted for Hell House. Tra la la!!!!