I hated Tall Tales with a passion. It actually made me detest Dean as a character

Oh gosh, really??

I'm big into shows that self reference as that's a big payoff for me being a regular viewer

I enjoy that, too, but I thought that there were maybe just a tad too many inside jokes in HB and they kinda started to lose impact as the show went on.

but it left a Sam sized hole in the episode.

Yep, Sam was pretty much MIA in HB, wasn't he? :-( I really don't like it when the brothers are separated for a good part of the episode.

In HH, towelclad!Sam made me all squishy and happy, despite me being a Dean!girl

LOL! Yes, me, too! I had to pick my jaw up off the floor. :-)

Thus I voted for Hell House. Tra la la!!!!

Thanks for voting and for the reason behind your choice!